Critical Thinking Task: Can you solve this normally? | Creative Problem-Solving Activity Years 3-6
$1.45
You won't be charged yet
Description
Can You Solve This Normally? | Creative Problem Solving Activity | Critical Thinking
What happens when the usual way of solving a problem is no longer available?
Can You Solve This Normally? is a quick, low-prep thinking routine that challenges students to recognise the obvious approach to a problem, identify why it cannot be used, and adapt their thinking to find a new way forward.
Instead of simply generating lots of solutions, students are asked to think strategically:
What would I normally do?
Why won’t that method work here?
What could I change?
What other strategy could I try?
This simple but powerful thinking routine helps students develop creative problem solving, flexible thinking, critical thinking, adaptability, and strategic reasoning.
Designed for Grades 3–8, this mini resource is ideal for critical thinking warm-ups, gifted and talented education, enrichment, classroom discussion, early finishers, and problem-solving lessons.
What’s Included
- 1 reusable Can You Solve This Normally? thinking routine
- Teacher Quick Start guide
- Ready-to-use teacher introduction script
- Model example for whole-class discussion
- Guided thinking prompts
- Support strategies and sentence starters
- Extension ideas for deeper thinking
- Sample challenges for applying the routine
- Student reflection prompts
Students Will Practise
Students develop their ability to:
- identify the obvious or usual approach to a problem
- recognise when a familiar strategy is unavailable or ineffective
- adapt their thinking when faced with constraints
- generate alternative approaches
- think creatively within limitations
- evaluate and improve strategies
- explain and justify their problem-solving process
- persist when their first approach does not work
- reflect on how changing constraints can change a solution
A Different Kind of Problem-Solving Challenge
Many problem-solving activities ask students to find an answer.
Can You Solve This Normally? changes the challenge.
Students first identify what they would normally do—then that approach is deliberately blocked. They must reconsider the problem, question their usual strategy, and find another way forward.
The aim is not simply to be creative. Students learn to adapt their thinking when familiar methods are unavailable, an important skill in problem solving, design thinking, STEM learning, and everyday decision making.
Flexible Classroom Uses
This Mini Thinking Routine can be used for:
- critical thinking warm-ups
- creative problem-solving lessons
- gifted and talented extension
- enrichment activities
- STEM thinking
- design challenges
- morning work
- early finisher activities
- partner and small-group discussion
- whole-class thinking challenges
- thinking journals
- metacognitive reflection
The routine can be revisited with different problems, restrictions, materials, and curriculum contexts, making it a flexible thinking tool that can be used throughout the year.
Why Teachers Will Love It
This routine is simple to introduce but creates genuine thinking.
Students cannot rely on the first strategy that comes to mind. They must recognise what has changed, work within a constraint, and adapt their approach.
The included teacher guidance makes the routine easy to launch, support, extend, and reflect on—without requiring lengthy preparation or specialist materials.
When the usual way doesn’t work, change your thinking.
One task. Many applications. Low prep. Deep thinking.
Grades 3–8 | Creative Problem Solving | Critical Thinking | Flexible Thinking | Problem-Solving Skills | Gifted Education | Enrichment Activity | STEM Thinking | Thinking Routine | Design Thinking | Reasoning Skills
Want a ready-to-use classroom version of this thinking task?
This task is also available as a Task Card set, designed for easy implementation, student independence, and repeat use.
Explore the Task Card version to extend this thinking routine in your classroom.
Start small. Think big. Stretch thinking.
Description
Can You Solve This Normally? | Creative Problem Solving Activity | Critical Thinking
What happens when the usual way of solving a problem is no longer available?
Can You Solve This Normally? is a quick, low-prep thinking routine that challenges students to recognise the obvious approach to a problem, identify why it cannot be used, and adapt their thinking to find a new way forward.
Instead of simply generating lots of solutions, students are asked to think strategically:
What would I normally do?
Why won’t that method work here?
What could I change?
What other strategy could I try?
This simple but powerful thinking routine helps students develop creative problem solving, flexible thinking, critical thinking, adaptability, and strategic reasoning.
Designed for Grades 3–8, this mini resource is ideal for critical thinking warm-ups, gifted and talented education, enrichment, classroom discussion, early finishers, and problem-solving lessons.
What’s Included
- 1 reusable Can You Solve This Normally? thinking routine
- Teacher Quick Start guide
- Ready-to-use teacher introduction script
- Model example for whole-class discussion
- Guided thinking prompts
- Support strategies and sentence starters
- Extension ideas for deeper thinking
- Sample challenges for applying the routine
- Student reflection prompts
Students Will Practise
Students develop their ability to:
- identify the obvious or usual approach to a problem
- recognise when a familiar strategy is unavailable or ineffective
- adapt their thinking when faced with constraints
- generate alternative approaches
- think creatively within limitations
- evaluate and improve strategies
- explain and justify their problem-solving process
- persist when their first approach does not work
- reflect on how changing constraints can change a solution
A Different Kind of Problem-Solving Challenge
Many problem-solving activities ask students to find an answer.
Can You Solve This Normally? changes the challenge.
Students first identify what they would normally do—then that approach is deliberately blocked. They must reconsider the problem, question their usual strategy, and find another way forward.
The aim is not simply to be creative. Students learn to adapt their thinking when familiar methods are unavailable, an important skill in problem solving, design thinking, STEM learning, and everyday decision making.
Flexible Classroom Uses
This Mini Thinking Routine can be used for:
- critical thinking warm-ups
- creative problem-solving lessons
- gifted and talented extension
- enrichment activities
- STEM thinking
- design challenges
- morning work
- early finisher activities
- partner and small-group discussion
- whole-class thinking challenges
- thinking journals
- metacognitive reflection
The routine can be revisited with different problems, restrictions, materials, and curriculum contexts, making it a flexible thinking tool that can be used throughout the year.
Why Teachers Will Love It
This routine is simple to introduce but creates genuine thinking.
Students cannot rely on the first strategy that comes to mind. They must recognise what has changed, work within a constraint, and adapt their approach.
The included teacher guidance makes the routine easy to launch, support, extend, and reflect on—without requiring lengthy preparation or specialist materials.
When the usual way doesn’t work, change your thinking.
One task. Many applications. Low prep. Deep thinking.
Grades 3–8 | Creative Problem Solving | Critical Thinking | Flexible Thinking | Problem-Solving Skills | Gifted Education | Enrichment Activity | STEM Thinking | Thinking Routine | Design Thinking | Reasoning Skills
Want a ready-to-use classroom version of this thinking task?
This task is also available as a Task Card set, designed for easy implementation, student independence, and repeat use.
Explore the Task Card version to extend this thinking routine in your classroom.
Start small. Think big. Stretch thinking.




