No True Scotsman Activity Pack: Critical Thinking​,​ Comprehension​,​ Writing and Vocabulary Skills

Learn how to spot the no true scotsman fallacy with Duchess and Bruno!

Our 20-page No True Scotsman Activity Pack dives into history to show how when people are confronted with the reality of their idea going horribly wrong, they just change the definition of their idea rather than admitting that their idea is wrong.

This pack dives deep into the fallacy with the Communist revolutions of the 20th century.

See how each time Communism was tried, revolutionaries declare that those examples were just not pure enough!

What’s Inside?

• Illustrated Historical Story: A gripping tale that is impossible to forget.
• Fallacy Breakdown: Clear definition, examples, and activities to master it.
• Real-Life Examples: Spot the fallacy in conversations, social media, news, and politics.
• Cool Comic + Analysis: A vibrant comic with a “Break It Down” section to dig deeper into the fallacy.
• Great Word Hunt: Fill in blanks to sharpen your skills.
• Fun Challenges: Crack the Code Breaker, play Match the Fallacy, and hunt for Where’s Gizmo!
• Draw Your Own Comic: Create your own story about the fallacy.
• Answer Sheet: Guides for teachers, parents, or group leaders.
• Plus much much more inside...

Why It’s Awesome:

This pack brings the fallacy to life with characters and history you can't forget. Made for middle school (ages 11+) and above, it’s also great for educators and families who love critical thinking and conversation.

How to Use It:

Download the file to print or view on a device. Print and laminate the activities, posters, cards, and guides for repeated use. Perfect for classrooms, homeschooling, tutoring, or family nights — ideal for ages 11+ and curious minds of all ages!

Want More?

• Find other packs at our TBS store: Duchess and Bruno.

Your Feedback Helps: After using this, please share a TBS review. Your ideas make our packs better! If anything’s off, let us know - we’ll send a fixed version fast.

Important Notes:

• We’re Here to Help! Downloads are final, but if you hit a snag or have suggestions, contact us. We’ll send an updated pack to keep your learning on track!
• Just for You: This pack is for personal use only - not for sharing, selling, or commercial use.

Join Duchess and Bruno to think critically and have unforgettable fun!

Curriculum Alignment:

The following outlines how the Activity Pack meets the standards or outcomes of the Australian National Curriculum, UK National Curriculum, and US Common Core State Standards. Although each of these curricula may not always explicitly mention "critical thinking" or "logical fallacies", they do encourage critical thinking (a core aspect of logical fallacies) in various ways from Grades 6 and above.

Here are the key ways in which critical thinking is emphasised in these national curricula:

Australia (Australian National Curriculum):

In the Australian National Curriculum, critical thinking is encouraged through the development of general capabilities. Some key aspects include:

Critical and Creative Thinking: This capability is explicitly mentioned and emphasizes skills such as problem-solving, analysis, and evaluation. Students are expected to think critically and creatively across various subject areas.

Research Skills: Students are encouraged to conduct research, analyze information, and use evidence to support their arguments, which involves critical thinking.

Inquiry-Based Learning: The curriculum promotes inquiry-based learning, where students are expected to ask questions, gather data, and draw conclusions, fostering critical thinking skills.

United Kingdom (UK National Curriculum):

In the UK National Curriculum, critical thinking is promoted through various subjects and general expectations:

English: Students are expected to analyze texts critically, evaluate evidence, and develop persuasive arguments.

Mathematics: Problem-solving and reasoning are central to mathematics. Students are encouraged to think critically and justify their solutions.

Science: The scientific method emphasizes critical thinking, analysis of evidence, and drawing conclusions.

History and Geography: Analyzing historical and geographical data and considering multiple perspectives require critical thinking.

Citizenship: Students explore political and social issues, requiring them to think critically about their rights, responsibilities, and societal challenges.

Information Literacy: In an age of information overload, students are expected to critically evaluate information sources for reliability and bias.

United States (Common Core State Standards):

In the US Common Core State Standards, critical thinking is integrated into subject-specific standards and the broader goals for students:

English Language Arts (ELA): Students are expected to analyze texts, evaluate arguments, and develop persuasive writing, requiring critical thinking.

Mathematics: The Standards for Mathematical Practice emphasize problem-solving, reasoning, and critiquing the reasoning of others.

Science: The Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS), adopted by many states, promote scientific inquiry, evidence-based thinking, and argumentation.

Research Skills: Students are encouraged to conduct research, evaluate information, and use evidence to support their claims.

Social Studies: Analyzing historical events, evaluating primary and secondary sources, and considering various perspectives require critical thinking.

These curricula may not explicitly state "critical thinking" as a standalone outcome, but they are designed to foster critical thinking skills within various subjects and educational activities. Educators play a significant role in promoting and assessing critical thinking within their teaching based on their region's curriculum expectations.